El-Syd's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Tall 'n Short]

Funny but...

I try to judge and vote fairly, but as far as reviewing this, I need to be honest I hold your work to a higher standard than the average NG artist, because I am aware of your skills. The dialogue was okay, but the chain of spam these flashes have generated, combined with the poor quality of the visuals, leaves me no choice but to vote 0

[Gears of Awesome]

thoroughly awesome

Very well done, great animation and voices, and very innovative way to do the ending credits.

[Edible Castle #10]

Hmmm

great drawing and animation and excellent voicework but this was a comedy and it just wasn't funny, the jokes and humor aren't necessarily bad, but they're not good either. I can see why a lot of people like it though, it's just not my thing.

[Dark Knight Interrogation]

hahahaha

That was good I liked batmans shenanigans at the beginning and especially got a kick out of the macdonalds scene, great voicework too.

[Awesome the Hedgehog]

nice

I enjoyed that, the drawing for robotniks assistant was funny and the whole thing was pretty amusing.

[Simple 3D Board Game Film]

Not bad

definitely a cool start on 3d animation, there wasn't really much of a plot or anything though and although the boardgame was well made its god to keep in mind, that it's not how many 3d objects you have it's how interesting they are, start on a minimalist mindset, and make simple yet effective scenery for your next experiment in 3d, you will find you can really do a lot with just a little, and the composition won't seem so busy. I'm speaking from a classical art standpoint, but the concept does carry over into 3d design.

Mariofan9 responds:

Thanks for the useful review. ^^
I'll take notes of what you've said.

[Awesome Compilation Vol 5]

Pretty good

The terAwsome gets me everytime, I love your ability to spoof a game even when it has no characters.