El-Syd's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Reginalds Valentine]

wow

would probably be a ten with the exception of the abrupt ending. First off, great style. Characters were simple yet well designed and effective, and cute too. Good use of color tones and shades made this a visually fun piece which when timed to the well chosen music was very fun to watch. Considering you said you did this in a day, I have to say that I am thoroughly impressed by your animatorial prowess.

Gerkinman responds:

I chose an abrubt ending because in life thats how these things tend to end.

[Happy Birthday Beautiful]

Nice

Great birthday flash, probaly the best I've seen, especially considering the original song, well sung and played. Visuals could've used backgrounds at times, but still, this was pretty great for a birthday flash

[Yo Daniel!]

hehe nice

The character designs were really well done, and I dug your sketchy style, and angle changes. Nice voicework and lyrics too, the sound could've been louder in parts though. Alll in all you have a very visually strong piece, and good overall direction.

[Birds and the Bees]

Nice work

That was very funny, the drawings were good especially the occasional goofy facial expressions. The comedy and voicework were also pretty well done here, keep up the good work SaltyPeach.

[Eric's Daydream]

heheh

very fun for how short it is , mainly I like the overal feel of the piece, which I think is strengthened by your music selection, character design and background/cityscape were also very cool in style, and really matched well with the music too. Keep up the good work.

[If You Don't Recycle]

hmmm

good message, man. Drawings and animation were both good and sound was as well, I have to say though, the al gore character's face was badly drawn and didn't really look or sound like al gore at all. al gore is an easy person to impersonate too, so it should be to hard to find someone who can do it.

[Ronin Warriors Pass Gas]

ehhh

The humor was soso it wasn't bad, just not good, plus all the voices were the same, the voicework was not bad, all the lines were clear and audible, they just had no character to them. The graphics were terrible, they weere just still pics with mouth movement added which always givesd a real bad look to a flash. Might be funny for younger viewers maybe, but 5 year olds really don't belong on newgrounds.

[Return of the joint]

heh

The ending way pretty fucked up, let me start with that, but aside from that, the humor was actually okay in this flash, nice use of the music and general feel, some of the drawings could've used some work, but some were pretty good, animation was okay, but there should have been more movement throughout the flash.