El-Syd's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Legend Of Zelda - NES]

okay

it was ok, you should've put a green backround behind all the screens, not just the one with the guy who gives you the sword though, cause it looks cheesy with the green rectangles around everyone. Other than that good zelda flash.

soja123 responds:

it's all green background dude!and... a 4?

[merrychristmas]

Nice e card

definitely brimming with christmas spirit. This is pretty good, you should make a collection and encourage people to download/send to their friends/family. It's probably a good way for an animator to get their name out there so they'll be more recognizable.

ewaldhew responds:

how to do that? anyway i'm passing this on to my friends and tell them to pass it on

[What the?Spider]

short but good

You may want to consider putting multiple shorts in a compilation, because somepeople are offset by the shortness, I judge on quality though so, 9/10 from me, and keep up the animation you have a good cartooning style.

TheSpicanator responds:

will do
thanks a lot

[Memoirs of a Snowman]

Well made

This turned out really good, you should definitely keep animating.

CyanideBreathmint responds:

Thank you.

[Flagship Torpedo]

Perfect match...

of style and music, also you have a really cool cartooning style, I can't wait to see more.

thecox801 responds:

thanks El-syd for the review. this animation definitely won't be my last. i appreciate the support.

[I Got Mine]

good

it ended a bit abruptly though., The start was pretty cool, you should've made it longer.

DiagnosticHour responds:

Thanks for the review. Now that I think about it, I should have made it longer. I just wanted to end it because I ran out of ideas for the day, and it seemed like i had been working on it for years.

[Elmo: Behind the Scenes]

That was good

you should animate it though, as even a crude animation is better than a still.

5/5 2/10, I was actually gonna give an 8 of 10 for the humor, until I read the authors comments, that its just a rip, but you do have a good eye for humor, try animating the next one you do, or maybe do one of your own skits. Either way, I definitely want to see more.

WasabiNinja-XX responds:

Thanks for the score! I'm lucky to get anything for ripping this audio. I do list the author, but you are all right; I should have done it myself. Just a quick question... how does 5/5 = 2/10? Twenty percent is only 1/5, not 5/5. Maybe you should get a math tutor.

[Bill Murray's Space Jam 5]

nice

You have a great narration voice.

AbsintheClock responds:

You have great sideburns

[Bill Murray's Space Jam 4]

Not bad

I think this is th efirst of the bill mrray tributes I've seen that has actual animation, so I'll give you an 8 for being above the curve. You may be in a spam syndicate, but I know that secretly you're actually an animator. I'm gald you're not afraid to animate, you should get you're friends in the CC into doing some FBF too. The slimer turned out real well.

SirCannabisClock responds:

edtrhwrthd

[Paper Problems]

Excellent cartooning

and very well put together, but it's too short and has no sound. Deifinitely a nice piece though, I can see from your author's comments that you plan to continue and make 10-20sec flashes. Might I suggest you release sets of four or five of them together, rather than just individual ten second long flashes. Other than that Great style, very fluid quality, looking forward to seeing what you create.

Shawntate responds:

Thanks alot El-Syd for the review. I agree it is pretty short, I do have a mini series that i have been putting off for some time now thats similar to the old tom and jerry cartoons. I plan on putting out the first short the end of December or early Jan. Im going to go ahead and bite the bullet and go for a 60 to 80 seconds long.